2023 OBSERVATIONS OF SF PENINSULA REAL ESTATE STORYLINES

Please “like” my Peter Tao Real Estate Facebook Page to get notification of my upcoming thoughts on the 2024 SF Bay 2024 real estate trends.

There was quite a bit of uncertainty at the start of 2023 about where real estate markets would go. One word, Supply and Demand….wait, that is three words. My most popular article Microeconomics for Real Estate I wrote in 2013, exactly 10 years ago, continues to get dozens of viewers every day due to being highly ranked in the Google SEO algorithm. To overly simplify, there is low supply amidst moderate demand for the following reasons:

DEMAND

While there are a good number of (potential) buyers out there, some percentage of them are unsure what to do given economic factors, such as interest rate, stock market and their own employment. There are highly qualified buyers interested, some are motivated while some are taking a cautious approach. There is moderate demand, although lower than post pandemic and prior to the current interest rate/inflationary spike.

SUPPLY

The move-up and down-size Buyers have significantly decreased due to the higher interest rate situation. Most owners have rates locked in at 2.5-4% with a lower property tax basis (in California). To purchase a larger home would mean to get a mortgage at 6.5-8% with a higher property tax basis; it would be a large financial step-up than in recent times. This dynamic puts a constraint on the supply side of the local real estate market.

PRICING MOVEMENTS

In a typical supply and demand curve, usually a low supply and moderate demand situation would create some price increases. In a “hot” “sellers market” which we’ve seen in many of the years over the last 8+ years, prices are increasing across all segments of the real estate market in the SF Peninsula market – condo, single family, multifamily, various cities, neighborhoods, starter, luxury. In 2023, we saw a real segmentation of pricing and demand – a flight to “quality”. By “quality”, single family residences that had some positive combination of nice move-in condition, good location, zones to popular schools, usable nice lots/backyard were the ones that saw multiple offers with some price increases from 2022.

Unlike past years in a really “hot” market, even with lower supply of listings, there were many properties that did not sell right away, sat on the market and/or went through price cuts. Because there were a lot of careful buyers out there, many buyers were more conservative in how they approached purchasing and preferred to wait for more attractive properties rather than making offers on a property that may have some major negative characteristic.

STRONG DEMAND EXAMPLE

The “Hallmark” neighborhood within Belmont Woods in Belmont up saw every (only 6 total) SFR sold in 2023 at $3.0 million and higher. See summary chart:

ADDRESSBDBASQ. FT.LOT SIZESOLD PRICECOMMENTS
23 Somerset Ct.43.53,02021,9003,300,000Big views, at trails
2884 Wakefield Dr.42.52,22017,3523,100,000Terraced sloped lot
2558 Somerset Dr.43.02,6727,0403,200,000Move in
2609 Somerset Dr.42.52,76011,9153,420,000Needs work, big flat lot
2741 Waltham Cross43.53,42710,2413,608,888Renovated, with pool
2759 Waltham Cross42.51,82012,2353,000,000Original, big flat lot
2023 Closed Transactions for SFR within “Hallmark” submarket of Belmont Woods, Belmont, CA

Hallmark has always been popular, but why has this pocket of homes in particular withstood macroeconomic conditions more so than most neighborhoods?

  • Typically above average size lots, some with views
  • Near waterdog park and cross country trails, wide streets with sidewalks
  • Neighborhood built from late 1960s to 1970s so floor plans of houses tend to be very appealing with vaulted ceilings so spacious interior feel w/curb appeal
  • Highly-regarded Belmont-Redwood Shores school district
  • 4 of the houses sold for multiple offers; 2 of the houses actually did not sell right away and went through price cuts due to being aggressively overpriced when first listed. Pricing appropriately is still extremely important in any market. 

SOFT DEMAND EXAMPLE

There have been numerous articles regarding the city of San Francisco and the challenges since the pandemic. While the SF condominium segment was particularly affected in 2021-2022, we did see SF condos as a whole stabilize in 2023 given the low inventory environment. A neighborhood still recovering though is West part of South of Market (“SoMa“). A few fundamental reasons:

  • Residences often work in financial district or start-up high tech area of South Beach and employees generally no working in offices yet
  • Mid-market corridor of SoMa which has been a economic redevelopment area lost many major high technology company tenants that employed many professionals
  • Pre-pandemic, SoMa saw a huge new construction boom of mid-rise condo projects saturating the western part of Sout of Market near mid-market area with inventory/supply

We know the markets go up and down and areas see growth and weakness. A key question is timing. Could this neighborhood be a buying opportunity in the near future from an investment stanpoint or is it still too early? There are just so many variables and nuances to consider which is what makes real estate so intersting to me and why understanding the MICRO-markets and balancing it with understaning of the macro financial marketsso important

MY 2023 REAL ESTATE SUMMARY

Sales volume is down YTD 2023 vs. 2022; preliminary estimates I am hearing has volume decreasing up to 20% year-over-year decrease of total volume in various part of SF Peninsula. I am so thankful for my clients and friends who trusted me this year, and who also referred me to their friends and family to navigate an uncertain, nervous marketplace due to higher mortgage rates that really changes the dynamics of the market. I will once again be top 8 in my Coldwell Banker office of 150 licensed Realtors.

As always, the opinions written in my articles are my personal opinions. Please feel free to contact Peter at peter.tao@cbnorcal.com anytime to brainstorm anything real estate, Warriors, Niners, local dog parks, schools, and/or restaurants. 😀 My next article will be about my forecast for 2024 SF Bay Area real estate markets. Thus, to be stay up to date on my thoughts, upcoming listings and interesting real estate news, please “like” my Peter Tao Real Estate Facebook Page. Happy holidays!

5 MISCONCEPTIONS REGARDING INTEREST RATES AND MORTGAGES

I have been considering writing an article related to mortgages for years now, as it seems most people do not really understand mortgages above and beyond that it is a loan to fund a real estate purchase. However, people do not seem to understand how they work, what external factors impact interest rates, types of pre-approvals or the history or future of interest rates. 

My BS and MBA degrees are in Finance; in a previous life, I was a high level strategist and dealmaker for top Fortune 500 financial services companies. Thus, I find myself explaining some of the nuances around mortgages and more recently (given the rapid rise) interest rate dynamics to my clients, but even many of my realtor/agent colleagues who are not well versed in finance.

The following are five major misconceptions regards mortgages:

  1. The Feds meet approximately every 6 weeks to discuss the Fed Funds (“FF”) rate, and they just announced another rate hike this week. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/07/26/fed-meeting-july-2023-.html. The FF rate is the rate that one financial institution lends funds to another on an “overnight” basis. Mortgage interest rates are tied to the 10 year treasury yields and only marginally correlated with movements in the FF rate. One is short-term and the other is medium/long term in duration. There is the concept of the yield curve (rate on Y and duration on X) which can be a rising, flat or upside down yield curve depending on the economy/market/forecast and that is a key element in how much movements in FF rate impacts mortgage rates.
  2. Mortgage rates at over 7% are more than double what they were just 2 years ago. Buyers are affected by the hike in rates due to the loan amount they qualify for now, and even more significantly, the psychological impact of wanting to wait until rates drop before making a purchase given “how high rates are now”. The chart below depicts the historical 30 year fixed average mortgage rates as compiled by government entity Freddie Mac and Bankrate.com.  Must be noted that prior to 2010 (just after the subprime mortgage implosion/meltdown), average interest rates were always above 5% and for the 30 year period from 1972 to 2001, and in 29 of the 30 years, average mortgage rates were above 7%. Interestingly, during the peak of the pandemic when I was cleaning out boxes in my garage, I found loan documents for my 1st home mortgage that had a 7.5% 30 year fixed interest rate which I refinanced 2 years later for around 6%. Yes, rates are much higher than they were 2 years ago, but by historical standards, the current rates are not considered outrageously high either. See my article I wrote 10 years ago for further perspective. https://taosiliconvalley.com/2013/11/08/mortgage-rates-have-risen-since-its-all-time-low-should-this-impact-your-timing-to-buy/
Year30-yr fixedYear30-yr fixed
20225.53%19967.76%
20213.15%19957.86%
20203.38%19948.28%
20194.13%19937.17%
20184.70%19928.27%
20174.14%19919.09%
20163.79%19909.97%
20153.99%198910.25%
20144.31%198810.38%
20134.16%198710.40%
20123.88%198610.39%
20114.65%198512.43%
20104.86%198413.88%
20095.38%198313.24%
20086.23%198216.04%
20076.40%198116.64%
20066.47%198013.74%
20055.93%197911.20%
20045.88%19789.64%
20035.89%19778.85%
20026.57%19768.87%
20017.01%19759.05%
20008.08%19749.19%
19997.46%19738.04%
19986.91%19727.38%
19977.57%
Source: Freddie Mac/Bankrate
  1. Mathematically the rise in mortgage rates has a direct impact on real estate prices. When rates were very low, consumers qualified for higher loan amounts. Rates precipitously increased starting Spring 2022. Real estate values in 2nd half 2022 dropped around 10-15% in the SF Peninsula area. While mortgage rates definitely factored into the price drop, it could be considered that other macro/micro factors may have had an even larger negative impact than rates. There were large layoffs with top technology companies, plus some major companies moved out of state; then, the stock market declined rapidly (Nasdaq in particular) affecting a meaningful segment of potential buyers. See my most read blog post that ranks very highly on the Google organic search algorithm discussing the impact on supply and demand in real estate. https://taosiliconvalley.com/2013/08/26/microeconomics-101-for-real-estate-2/
  2. When I am the listing agent representing a Seller, I always do my due diligence on the “strength” of a “preapproval” letter for someone who submitted an offer on my listing. Many real estate agents think having a letter from a mortgage lender/broker that says “preapproval” is strong and a done deal. Most of these letters are NOT “underwriting preapproved”, but really a “prequalification” letter with just a different title. To be considered a “preapproval”, the file would need to be submitted to a lender underwriting department with a full application file. Most of the time, a letter is generated by the mortgage consultant/officer who reviews the documents and possibly  runs a credit check before calculating a loan amount and generating a (prequalification) letter. If the mortgage officer is highly experienced, detailed and competent, this is still strong. This is why I want to know exactly how strong a preapproval/prequalification letter is when I discuss a deal with my seller or buyer client so they understand the risks.
  3. In my open houses, I have heard potential buyers say that they prefer to wait until interest rates decrease again before seriously contemplating purchasing a property so they can qualify for a higher loan amount and be able to purchase a bigger property. Unfortunately, in the SF Peninsula area it may not work like that. If rates go down, then all the other buyers can qualify for higher amounts too which may drive up prices. Additionally, there will be others who are thinking the same thing so demand/competition overall may be less with higher rates. The risk of waiting is, no one knows how long it will be before rates drop 1-2% as it may be years. Lastly, the other strategy would be to purchase with the higher interest rate if the right property comes up and financially a buyer can afford it, and assuming they may be able to refinance if/when the rates go back down in the future.

As always, if anyone wants to discuss real estate, economy, stock market, or just the Warriors or Niners, feel free to call/email/text. Please feel free to subscribe to this blog or <Like> my FB Real Estate Page at https://www.facebook.com/PeterTaoProperties.

LESSONS LEARNED AFTER 14 YEARS AS A YOUTH SPORTS FATHER, COACH, AND LEADER

Why am I writing a youth sports article on a real estate website?

First, I am passionate about youth sports, and one of the reasons I left my former VP-level Silicon Valley job for a full time real estate career is it allowed me flexibility to coach my children’s sports teams. Second, many of my real estate clients have young children starting youth sports, so I thought it helpful to summarize my learnings and observations over the last 14 years to share.

My experiences with youth sports is rooted in having been an involved father to my college-age son and my high school daughter. During their childhood, I volunteered to head or assistant coach 20 different soccer and basketball teams, served on the board of our area’s largest non-profit youth basketball league, and experienced the rapidly growing world of “club” sports. I have seen the best of youth sports and the unheathy side of it too.

I am always excited when I am able to provide my real estate clients detailed hyper-local feedback on public/private schools, dog parks, athletic fields/facilities, restaurants, commute options, and the youth sports scene which all have ancillary effects on the real estate market.

PLAYING FOR LOCAL, VOLUNTEER CITY LEAGUES YIELDS INTANGIBLE BENEFITS

If my 7 year old child doesn’t join a competitive club team and commit year round, (s)he will fall behind others, and not have a shot at a college scholarship.

Love the AYSO Key 6 Philosophies

The current trend is joining a club team at a younger and younger age. Rationale is for kids to get an “experienced (non-parent)” coach for skill development, better competition, and more focus. Those are certainly viable benefits, but I believe parents and kids underestimate the intangible social/personal benefits to remaining in your local volunteer-based city leagues as long as possible before switching to a club.

  • Making friends within one’s community for both kids and adults from the local teams. 
  • Prior to my daughter playing AAU and HS basketball, she also played for a high level club soccer team. Her fondest elementary school sports memory? Eating oranges and the awesome banners from her U6/U8 AYSO soccer teams with the Blue Diamonds and Star Strikers. I believe all children should play AYSO as long as possible, and I’m pretty sure the kids athletic and committed enough to play college/HS will end up there regardless if they play AYSO or a club team at age 7.
  • More flexibility for children to play other sports and not have to commit to a year round single sport schedule.
  • Less expensive and time spent driving far distances to games. I recall a regular season club soccer game (single game, not a tournament) 4 hours drive away in Fresno…WTF?!

POSITIVE COACHING & SKILL DEVELOPMENT MORE IMPORTANT THAN WINNING

Those who knew me when I was younger may find that title amusing, as I used to be hyper-competitive with games of any kind. Do not choose a club team based on how many tournament trophies/medals they may post on social media. Winning trophies is only a small correlation to good coaching. 

Coach Royce focused on skill development, positive coaching, and work ethics
  • While all coaches want to win, the top coaches use practices for mostly skill development than on “set plays” and care more about the future than immediate wins and losses. Huge thank you to Coaches Anna Sterrett, Miranda Seto at Fever AAU girls basketball, coach Melanie Murphy at Torch AAU girls basketball, and my friend Coach Royce Nelson at Supreme Kourt AAU boys basketball who my kids played for and run fantastic programs.
  • I’ve observed opposing coaches scream at the top of their lungs at 11 year olds even when they had a 30 point lead in basketball or a 5-1 lead in soccer. They think they are motivating higher level performance, but they are only demoralizing kids. I believe in the Positive Coaching Alliance philosophies.
  • Unfortunately, I’ve seen terrific, strong players quit a sport because of just one bad coach; but I’ve also seen kids who were top club players change sports because they found a different sport “more fun” and motivational after experiencing a positive, development-oriented coach.
Incredible parent coaches Joe & Todd and group of girls who are top HS players in different sports now
  • Special shout out to the amazing parent volunteer coaches I had the privilege of coaching 2 or more seasons (many other awesome parents I coached 1 season with) of a sport with and did so with passion and dedication – Peter Anderson, Steve O’Driscoll, Steve Scholl, Gary Chiang, Joe Haws, Todd Leyte-Vidal, and Tim Netane.

STEP UP AND VOLUNTEER COACH!

Are you fearful for being “unqualified” in that sport or lack of free time?

Every city youth sports league needs volunteer parents to help coach and other roles to run the league and teams. Every parent is busy. I ran the local National Jr. Basketball chapter for a few years and on the Board for many more, and I am proud of recruiting many committed volunteer parent coaches and Board members. I would encourage all parents to step up and volunteer for something in one league/sport/activity.

  • You don’t necessarily need to have played the sport growing up to be a good coach for elementary school age kids. Practice plans, skill development drills, coaching tips are plentiful on Youtube. Focus on fundamentals, few fun games, some concepts, a few strategy/plays, and a positive attitude.
  • Partner with a parent of one of your kid’s friend’s parents to coach with.
  • Ask parents on your team to help out with practices whenever they are able.
So blessed that these now college young men who I coached when they were in elementary/middle school participated in my 50th birthday basketball tournment w/my old guys basketball friends
  • To this day, I run into kids, now young adults who I coached when they were younger. When I hear “hi coach”, it totally makes my day that they remembered me.

Don’t Stress, It All Works Out in the End

As parents, we fear that even with planning for every circumstance, our kids don’t make the U11 all star team, their athletic goals in high school or some other disappointment.

Middle school undefeated championship team led by the awesome coach Tim. These players are now in high school with 5 playing basketball, 4 volleyball and a 1 soccer! #specialteam

Having coached many teams and following local high school athletics in my community, I know most of the boys and girls who were “all-star” level players in elementary/middle schools in baseball, soccer, basketball. Would it surprise you to know only a minority percentage of these all-star players became a varsity starter in high school at those sports? Here are some of the reasons: 

  • Kids playing a year round club sport simply burned out when they started specializing at young age, and they transitioned to a different sport.
  • Physically growing and maturing at different ages so those who grew taller and stronger at an earlier age may just be average size as a high schooler.
  • High schools with a lot of students draw from wider geography plus the 4 year age range so it is much more competitive to make a HS varsity team.
  • Of course, there were some who we could all tell would be a superstar in a particular sport realized their potential and it’s great fun watching them play now..

FINAL THOUGHTS

I am proud that both my kids love sports, believe in fitness, and made a lot of friends through their teams. I personally did some things right, but also made my share of mistakes too.

  • My now college son realized HS basketball may be tough at only 5′ tall in 8th grade. He picked up tennis “for fun” as a 7th grader and really enjoyed it while playing for coaches Holly and Margaret who were awesome and made the game fun.
  • He started training seriously starting 8th grade with one of the area’s top tennis coaches, John Hubbell at Bay Club. Some said he started too late for high level tennis. Through his hard work, good coaching, and playing USTA tournaments, he improved his game rapidly to become 4 year starter for his HS team and captain his senior year.
  • The irony is he is now 6′ feet tall having a great time playing pickup basketball, intramural volleyball and club tennis in college.
Daughter trying to defend my sister’s college best friend’s all-league daughter Bailey
  • My daughter is playing HS varsity basketball, and this upcoming season will be fun as she continues to shoot up in height while having a strong spring/summer AAU season playing for coaches of one of the top HS/AAU programs in Northern California.
My garage – 17 basketballs, 4 footballs, 7 soccer balls, 12 tennis rackets, 2 golf clubs, 2 gloves, 2 balls, 3 discs,1 ping pong table, 4 snorkels, 3 hockey sticks, 1 bat, 1 volleyball, 5 bikes, 1 soccer net, 1 blocking pad, 2 rollerblades, 2 scooters, 3 softballs, basket of tennis balls, and 1 boogie board
  • Perhaps the only positive thing to come out of the shelter-in-place during the pandemic is not having organized activities. We actually really enjoyed riding bikes, throwing the football around, hiking local trails, competing in silly games, and playing ping pong in the garage. Old school fun which I hope all of today’s kids will carry with them into adulthood.

As always, feel free to reach out with me with anything in the SF Peninsula with regards to youth sports, best restaurants, outdoor activities, dog parks, and of course, residential real estate!

A RAPIDLY CHANGING SF PENINSULA REAL ESTATE MARKET…SHOULD BUYERS WAIT IT OUT OR JUMP IN?

 “Be fearful when others are greedy, and be greedy only when others are fearful.” – Warren Buffett

Investopedia defines “herd instinct/mentality” as a phenomenon where people join groups and follow the actions of others under the assumption that other individuals have already done their research. Herd instincts are common in all aspects of society, even within the financial where investors follow what they perceive other investors are doing, rather than relying on their own analysis. 

I wrote in my last real estate article on 5/4/22 about Huge Decrease in Supply in Q1 and Spike in Demand. Over the last few months, we have seen a material decline in the financial stock market, a spike in inflation, and an increase in mortgage interest rates that have really impacted the local real estate markets. Some have estimated that 30-40% of buyers who were actively looking to purchase during Q1 have postponed their search due to the macro dynamics. Real estate prices have declined in recent months, but that’s from a large rise of 15%+ for SFRs (condos didn’t see quite as much) in most areas during the 1st 5 months of 2022 so prices are still meantingfully net higher than from 2021 values.

Certainly, any buyers whether 1st time or move up who elect to wait and see how various aspects of the market and their personal situation shakes out until things stabilize would be totally rational.

  1. In the high technology-centric Bay Area, many people’s liquidity/down payment are invested in the NASDAQ stock market which is down 21% YTD. People who rely on stock options from a single company to fund down payments may be down even more.
  2. We are hearing about layoffs regularly these days, so there may be a bit of uncertainty as to job stability.
  3. Jumbo fixed 30 year mortgage interest rates have risen from a low of 3% last year to over 5% raising monthly payments and thus affecting loan amounts.
  4. There is always a fear that prices may decline further (suppose not much different than in rising markets either!)

Above, I reference a famous Warren Buffet quote and start this article defining herd mentality. There is one strategy around investment theories to not follow the herd and always do what the herd do. The following would be some reasons to actively seek to purchase an owner occupied home when others may want to wait a bit.

  1. Most people’s financial situation has been negatively impacted in the last few months, but to the extent that your financial situation makes it tenable to still make a purchase, there is significantly less buyer competition. In Q1, most every SFR in a good neighborhood at $3m and under often yielded 3-15 offers while buyers had less than a week to decide. Currently, there are more of choices for buyers with much less or no competition.
  2. Buying a house to live in yields intangible emotional benefits above and beyond just a financial return. This is a perspective I tell all my owner-occupied buyers regardless of market conditions.
  3. It is nearly impossible to perfectly time a financial or real estate market. In the SF Bay Area, like the general financial markets, over a 7-10 year medium term horizon, Bay Area estate prices are generally always net higher.
  4. For the move up buyer who currently own a property and wish to wait for their own value to rise again first, just a reminder that if your smaller property rise, your move up property will likely also rise, but at the higher price point.
  5. The higher interest rates no doubt has affected payments and mortgage amount. All of this macro trends has directly and indirectly affected real estate values to account for that dynamic. Two things to consider: 1) read my article from 5 years ago on Historical Mortgage Rates that even at our current rates, it’s actually not considered that high (my 1st house purchase, my mortgage was over 7% and I refinanced a year later at 6%! Crazy, huh?!), and 2) if and when mortgage rates start to drop again, there is always the possibility of refinancing to a lower rate in the future, so the current rates is likely not locked in for the entire 30 years.

Of course, if your liquidity was all in cryptocurrency or in a single recent IPO unprofitable company who has lost most of its value this year, then now may not be the right time to purchase. If your company has gone through a couple rounds of layoffs and you are not feeling confident, it may be best to hold off. There are pros and cons for every individual situation. While I am a realtor, I have the unique background where I have lived in the SF Bay Area for last 25 years going through multiple periods of growth and recessions, in past life been VP at several high profile technology companies that had major exits and blowups so I understand our local technology markets, and finally, I hold two degrees in Finance. Thus, I always am happy to brainstorm with clients and friends on evaluating the risk and rewards of various options.

HUGE DECREASE IN SUPPLY IN Q1, RISING RATES & MY RECORD BREAKING HOUSE SALE & UPCOMING LISTINGS

Wow, what a Q1 2022. Just an astounding first few months of the new year. The market is RAPIDLY shifting, if you are about to buy and/or sell, it’s critical that you work with someone who has the pulse of the market and who you trust to provide you with unfiltered advice.

  • Even a couple month ago trends/date is often outdated
  • So called “experts” are just looking for soundbites and do not know the fine nuances of the market
  • Real estate is highly localized and the submarkets may be materially different from one another

Below is a matrix summarizing SOLD data for single family residences from February 1 to March 31 from 2020, 2021 and 2022 in San Carlos, Belmont and Burlingame. I chose those 3 cities as representative of mid-Peninsula, but should be directionally similar to other cities. The matrix is quite telling:

Burlingame, San Carlos, Belmont All SFR – Sold between February 1 and March 31

20202021YOY%2022YOY%
# Sold9015067%79-47%
Avg List2,154,5572,304,8457%2,515,1449%
Avg Sold2,221,5982,512,96313%2,930,63717%
% Above List3.1%9.0%16.5%
Avg $/sq. ft.1,1461,25610%1,50120%
.
  • Q2 2020 was the start of the pandemic and shelter-in-place
  • 2021 had 150 sold transactions to start the new year with a 9% average increase from list to sold price and the average $/square feet increased YOY of 10%, as buyers demand rapidly increased 
  • Start of 2022 saw a MASSIVE decrease in # of sold transaction by 47% (almost half of last year’s volume) which led to a $/square feet increase of 20% with incredibly competitive multiple offer bidding wars for most houses jumping 16.5% from list price (my most popular blog post from 9 years ago is still highly relevant https://taosiliconvalley.com/2013/08/26/microeconomics-101-for-real-estate-2/)

As I write this at the start of May, we still see strong buyer demand, but this has flattened a bit, due to the following:

  • Spike in mortgage interest rates impact the loan qualifications
  • High inflation affects consumer confidences
  • NASDAQ has dropped nearly 20% since start of the year which affects down payments due to high technology centric buyers
  • Buyer fatigue from losing out multiple times in past 6 months

My Incredible San Mateo Village Listing from Q1

I had a sweet listing of a 4bd/3ba completely modernized home with high end finishes and exquisite design details. I helped pick out some of the finishes including tile work when preparing the house for sale. Check out the full listing pictures/details. https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/3630-Santiago-St-San-Mateo-CA-94403/15538642_zpid/

  • Approximately 250 people attended the only weekend of open houses. It was an absolute madhouse.
  • 18 groups requested disclosures packages
  • List price was $2,198,000, we received multiple offers, and it closed at $2,680,000 to very excited buyers.

What was the secret formula?

  • Totally renovated house that had some interesting style, unique high-end finishes
  • Terrific location in heart of San Mateo Village
  • Coldwell Banker and my aggressive marketing program absolutely blasted online, email, television, neighborhood mailers, and print advertising. Anyone looking in the mid-Peninsula saw this listing!
  • Underrated part of optimizing results is marketing the high value parts of property, understanding buyer psychology and creating a process to motivate offers from qualified buyers, and being able to talk to buyers and their agents explaining the nuances of the property.

My Upcoming Listings in May/June

  1. Woodside Plaza in Redwood City – we are in the final preparations on putting this exquisite 3bd/2ba 1650 sq. ft. house with a totally sweet 350 sq. ft. ADU/Cottage w/full bathroom, and has the best backyard entertaining area I’ve ever seen (not located in Hillsborough or Atherton!). The backyard has this large vaulted covered patio area that has an entire outdoor kitchen, recessed lighting, heat lamp that can be used all year round, that then extends to another patio area with a built-in BBQ area next to a hot tub and grass area on an oversized lot. This is a must see just to check it out.
  2. A large 5bd/4ba Daly City house – we are preparing this house for early June. Terrific location nearby Serramonte Mall, and transportation options. Upstairs is 3bd/2ba, and downstairs has permitted large living space with 2bd/2ba and living areas.

If you or know anyone interested, feel free to contact me at Peter.Tao@cbnorcal.com, and I can try to allow showing as we get closer to coming on market. Or call me if you just wanted to talk real estate, travel or the Golden State Warriors!

My SF Peninsula 2022 Real Estate Predictions Based on a Busy 2021 Year

Please “like” my FB Page https://www.facebook.com/PeterTaoProperties to stay updated on blog post articles, upcoming listings and interesting things I see at properties around the SF Peninsula!

Reading many so called “experts”, “analysts”, and fellow Realtors predictions for residential real estate in the SF Peninsula market over the past weeks leads me to write my annual end-of-year/start-of-new-year observations and predictions. 2021 was one of my busiest years as a Realtor in the SF Peninsula and I expect strong deal flow in 2022. The following are 7 major topics often discussed in mainstream media – some of which I concur with but others I believe to be significantly overblown or will not materially affect our local markets.

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association
  • Current run up of real estate price appreciation is only minimally due to low interest rates – although a lower interest rate is a mathematically positive factor, other macro factors significantly influence pricing in our area more than rates. A very large number of Bay Area buyers have some combination of savings due to frothy stock market allowing for high down payment and/or well paying high salaries, so potential creep up with rates will not affect price points as much as most people are predicting.

  • People moving out of the Bay Area has had minimal impact. A couple of my seller clients in 2021 moved to other states. The supply and demand imbalance quickly absorbed any small incremental new inventory due to a geographic move.
  • There continues to be a high demand, low supply imbalance going into 2022 for single family residences. I am aware of an influx of listings coming on the market in the next few months, but there are also many buyers who were not successful in purchasing a home in 2021 and some new buyers ready for aggressively look in 2022. The link is my most read post that still gets dozens of random readers who find it through Google organic search. https://taosiliconvalley.com/2013/08/26/microeconomics-101-for-real-estate-2/
  • Many people in SF Peninsula work in high technology and have high liquidity from a frothy stock market and the many 2021 local IPOs. Buyers have capital for a large down payment making for increasingly strong buyer profiles – this is unlike in 2007-2008 at the height of the last market boom where many buyers “qualified” for large subprime loans with minimal to no down payment. There has been a softening of Nasdaq to start 2022 so we will see what happens to the broader financial markets.
  • Location and lot have always been arguably the most important factor in real estate; the pandemic may have put even more of a premium on those factors as homeowners value a nice outdoor space in good locations. Where I have seen very high sale prices often were with houses that had large flat lots and/or views and/or premium locations.
  • As I wrote in a recent blog post article, construction costs and project timelines have increased precipitously. All contractors and suppliers are backed up thus making even cosmetic remodels much more challenging and expensive. Thus, move-in condition houses in good locations command a premium relative to fixer uppers.  https://taosiliconvalley.com/2021/09/23/real-estate-construction-costs-skyrockets-in-sf-peninsula-what-is-impact-to-real-estate-prices/
  • I helped several clients purchase rental property or 2nd homes in 2021 as they seek to diversify their investment assets while taking advantage of low interest rates. Many residential agents, even top producing ones would not know how to advise on cap rates mean and its interplay between appreciation potential vs near term cash flow as well as understanding of property management and leasing. Here is one of the first blog posts I wrote 8 years ago on an “investment that didn’t make sense for a friend’ that helped articulate some of the many variables on buying an investment property. https://taosiliconvalley.com/2013/12/06/an-example-of-a-real-estate-investment-that-just-didnt-make-sense/. The 2nd home markets like Sonoma/Napa, Lake Tahoe, Monterey/Carmel real estate values skyrocketed in 2021, from the many Bay Area buyers.

The start of 2022 will be quite interesting to say the least. The initial group of properties that hit the market in the 1st couple months will really set the tone of this year. This article represents my personal insights and not related to any companies I am affiliated with. Additionally, the local markets can and will change rapidly due to macro and microeconomic factors. Thank you to my clients and friends who worked with me and/or referred me to their friends in 2021. I look forward to hearing from many of you in 2022 and get an update how you are all doing.

I can be reached at peter.tao@cbnorcal.com.

Real Estate Construction Costs Skyrockets in SF Peninsula…What is Impact to Real Estate Prices?

Yes, yes it does, but in different ways depending on the segment. First, let’s discuss why costs/budgets have significantly increased over the past year .

  • During the pandemic, while people were shelter-in-place, the need to renovate their existing home increased precipitously so there was an increase in demand for contractor labor.
  • With the combined increase in demand for labor, as well as some migration of contractors out of the area, skilled contractors started getting booked up months in advance creating a labor shortage.
  • As general contractors and sub-contractor’s job pipeline get backed up from 3-6 months in advance, they start to increase their bids/estimates on job proposals increasing pricing.
  • Early in the pandemic when imports totally stopped at the ports/borders, there were major supply chain problems with many industries. Materials like cabinets, countertops, fixtures and many other key house materials stopped coming in from countries like China, inventory became scarce in certain areas. 
  • Good example was in early 2021, lumber prices increased by 5-7x – not a typo. Fortunately, lumber prices have come down.
  • With low inventory, prices began to increase.
  • There are shortages of key finish items, such as high-end appliances with “smart features” that are seeing lead times of 6 months. Apparently, a backed-up supply chain issue created by a shortage of “chips” that is a key material in the production of certain appliances.
  • So with all these delays, cost increases, labor shortages, general contractors must then factor in just more time, effort, challenges, delays that they also need to increase their projected margin to somewhat factor these issues into the equation.

What do any of these factors impacting construction costs have to do with real estate values? Here are some examples of the impacts I have seen first hand as both listing agent and buyers agent in the San Francisco Peninsula marketplace.

  • Home buyers know about rising costs and long lead times that many buyers who would have considered a fixer upper, no longer will contemplate one. Thus, move-in condition homes are in higher demand than ever before.
  • Conversely, fixer uppers in good neighborhoods that may have sold a few years ago with multiple offers, may not still sell right away or command as many offers and the spread between a fixer upper and recently renovated home have widened.
  • Homeowners are finding it much more challenging doing a substantial home renovation or an expansion project due to this significantly increasing cost and longer project timeline. I have two different clients who have been planning an expansion project in  the Peninsula over the past year including architectural renderings and general contractor estimates. Unfortunately, the estimates over the last 6 months increased by more than 50% making the financial economics of a home expansion not as clear cut as in the past.
  • For example, let’s say a homeowner bought a San Mateo SFR 5 years ago for $1m that was a 3bd/2ba 1400 square feet that is now worth $1.5m. They want to expand to a 4bd/2.5ba 2100 square feet for $700k; after completion, it will be a beautiful fully renovated house worth $2.5m imputing $300k of “sweat equity”. However, let’s say the new budget for that project is now $1.0m. Then, the “sweat equity” benefit is negligible and the benefits would be the finished product being to the precise taste of the owner and ability to remain in the neighborhood; the downside is over 1 year of planning, decisions, project management and moving into a temporary apartment. The alternative is to just buy a bigger, nicer one for $2.5m and sell the smaller one. Of course, the decision is much more financially, psychologically and logistically more complex than that, but you can now see the dilemma.
  • The net is that there are more move-up buyers in the market, which is why the $2-3m price point in good school districts with renovated houses and usable backyards to be highly competitive.
  • Interestingly, I am seeing more houses listed by developers be put on the market to be sold with approved plans for a home buyer to construct. Their reasoning is they are too busy with other projects to start which likely is true. However, I am pretty certain the other reason is  their tightening projected profit margins is squeezing builders.

As always, feel free to contact me at peter.tao@cbnorcal.com if you wish to discuss anything real estate related. Any advice from those who have recently undergone a renovation project? Any feedback or real world renovation war stories?

Real Estate Case Studies from My Very Busy 1st Half 2021

Please “like” my Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/PeterTaoProperties for update on my blog posts.

PETER TAO SELECT CASE STUDIES (AKA “WAR STORIES”) 1ST HALF 2021

As a Realtor, the 1st half of 2021 has been incredibly busy despite many challenges for buyers, sellers and Realtors. While I am always happy when I optimize sale price on a listing or successfully win in a multiple offer situation for buyers, I have been particularly fulfilled in the last few months navigating an incredibly competitive SF Peninsula real estate market. I completed a diversity of transactions/situations that few agents ever work on let alone just in a few months which made for very interesting and rewarding transactions. The following are a few case studies highlighting a few deals.

War Story #1 – S. San Francisco Duplex

Clients: Buyers who I helped buy their 1st mid-Peninsula house many years ago on their first offer are about to start a large expansion project.

.

Situation: Clients will need to move out for a year for construction on existing residence, so they asked me to look for a 2BD condo for up to $1.4m to purchase and move into; after completion of renovations,  they will move back to their house, and then rent out the condo.

Challenge: There are condos within their budget in good locations. However, due to low cap rates for condos in prime locations, and a high monthly HOA, the unit would have negative cash flow as a rental with a mortgage.

Solution: As they had advised that part of the reason for purchase was to diversify their investment portfolio away from the stock market, I described the possibility of a duplex and some of its advantages if they had financial flexibility to do so.

Result: Rather than spend $1.2-1.4 million for a a 2bd/2ba 1k square feet condo in an older building with monthly HOA of $500+, they raised their budget by a few hundred thousand and acquired a beautiful Spanish Meditteranean-style duplex with 3bd/2ba floor plan on each side that had been recently remodeled just a few years ago. We were able to get it at under list price, and they got a vacant unit rented out within a week of purchasing.

Takeaways: There is demand for multifamily properties but not the wild bidding wars of SFRs. Super low interest rates make investment real estate appealing for those with capital for down payments. Clients were successful because they are numbers-oriented, knew the type of asset they wanted, and had a good plan to become landlords

War Story #2 – San Mateo Village with Outdoor Oasis

Clients: Sellers with a growing family unit who I helped buy their 1st home several years ago wished to upgrade to a larger house.

Situation: Clients were undecided about selling 1st before buying or buying 1st before selling. I helped them assess the advantages and disadvantages of both options as well as the financial risk factors and life logistical challenges for each.

Challenge: The $2.6 to 3.3 million price range for a 4BD house in a good school district has been a highly competitive segment. Selling first would put them in a better financial position to compete in a multiple offer situation, and allow them to look for a house at a higher price point. However, both clients work demanding jobs and have a young toddler; thus, being “out of the market” and having to live in a temporary rental given their situation is just not tenable. 

Having looked at houses at a lower price point where they did not need to sell their current house first, they realized they could not get the space they needed based on their existing lender preapproval.

Solution: Clients had been told a maximum price they could afford without selling their existing house first. However, I realized the lender they were working with did not specialize in “purchase mortgages”, so they did not have the breadth of products addressing my clients’ situation. I outlined scenarios of lenders who had more options who would factor in that their current home would either be sold immediately thereafter or used as a rental home. They got pre-approval from a different lender at a higher price point.

Result: They bought a larger house they sought and needed While they considered keeping their 1st house as a rental, they decided they did not have time to become a landlord so they decided to sell. We then had time to fully prepare their current house to list on the market after it was vacant. This allowed me and sellers to do some renovations and stage the house, so it showed really nicely accentuated by an incredible backyard. After my full marketing program blasting the marketplace, we received 9 terrific offers and very happy sellers and buyers.

Takeaways: Using a mortgage lender who specializes in purchase transactions is important, as is having a real estate agent who knows the intricacies of mortgages and financials. Move up Buyers face a very tricky and scary challenge in this real estate market, but can be successfully navigated. Being able to do prep work, staging a property, coming up with an appropriate list price is key to optimizing value on a listing. 

War Story #3 – SF Dogpatch New Construction Condo

Clients: Buyers sought out a pied-a-terre in Sonoma or possibly San Francisco..

Situation: Clients who were long time friends were interested in investing in a 2nd home in Sonoma where they viewed it as a near term pied-a-terre and a medium term retirement home.

Challenge: After viewing many houses in Sonoma and coming close to making an offer, clients realized that prices in Wine Country were being driven up by multiple offers at a price point higher than what they wanted to spend. They then discovered their teenage children were not as keen to spend time up in Sonoma as they had expected..

Solution: As I knew my friends enjoyed good food, drinks and entertainment, we started discussing the condo market in San Francisco. On a last minute decision, I suggested we visit a few SF condos on the way back from a Sonoma visit one weekend

Result: They are now happy owners of a 2BD/2BA new construction condo in the red hot Dogpatch neighborhood walking distance to Chase Center, AT&T Park, restaurants, coffee/boba shops, and all that SF has to offer. They acted quickly in submitting an offer as their particular unit had access to a larger outdoor space than normal. I represented my clients and secured the unit which ended up getting multiple offers; I also negotiated upgrade credits too. Best of all, their children are very excited to make use of the condo on weekends.

Takeaways: Vacation areas like Sonoma, Carmel, Lake Tahoe are red hot with skyrocketing prices. Buyers are returning to the SF condo market after a 2020 slowdown, but value can still be had relative to single family residences. I am able to represent Buyers for new construction buildings but need to schedule and attend the 1st showing appointments.

High Level Predictions for 2nd Half 2021

  • Buyers had been severely hindered with their ability to view properties without public open houses. Finally, open houses are back.
  • Expect there to be a significant summer slowdown in activity with fewer listings and buyers in the marketplace due to what looks like a busy summer vacation travel season.
  • As employees slowly return to the offices full or part time, traffic on the freeway, roads and bridges will slowly pick up again, albeit not as bad as pre-pandemic.
  • There will continue to be an imbalance between strong demand to purchase real estate and limited supply in the <$3m price point despite news of people moving out of the Bay Area.
  • Crazy low interest rates certainly help fuel the real estate values. However, eventual movements higher with interest rates will have little impact.
  • As buyers who lose out multiple times with single family residences, demand for condos will increase as buyers become frustrated.

The insights and opinions are my own and not that of any companies I am affiliated with. The SF Peninsula real estate market is rapidly changing, and each property is unique. As always, don’t hesitate to call me for any real estate purpose or otherwise. 

Please “like” my Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/PeterTaoProperties for update on my blog posts.

Some of My Sold Properties During Shelter-in-Place 2020 – Six Key Takeaways that are Underreported

PETER TAO’S SELECT SOLD PROPERTIES DURING SHELTER-IN-PLACE 2020
Home 1
STUNNING MARINA-STYLE HOME IN CENTRAL RICHMOND DISTRICT WITH TERRIFIC INDOOR-OUTDOOR SPACE
686 24th Ave, San Francisco (Represented Sellers)
Sold for $1,675,000 w/12 fantastic offers at 20% above list
HR
Home 2
GORGEOUS MODERNIZED 4BD/3BA HOME WITH LARGE YARD, DETACHED STUDIO & TOP SAN CARLOS SCHOOLS
Dartmouth Ave, San Carlos (Represented Buyers)
Won against competitive multiple offers on Buyers’ first house offer
HR
Home 3
WONDERFUL EICHLER ON HUGE FLAT 12K LOT IN HIGHLANDS NEIGHBORHOOD
2047 Ticonderoga Drive, San Mateo (Represented Sellers)
Sold for $2,055,888 at 8% above list price
HR
Home 4
REGAL 4BD EDWARDIAN IN CENTRAL RICHMOND CLOSE TO EVERYTHING OWNED BY SAME FAMILY FOR 50 YEARS
547 18th Ave, San Francisco, CA (Represented Seller)
Sold for $2,022,200 in 7 days

Many real estate articles during this unprecedented 2020 have espoused data with misleading conclusions. Between my BS/MBA degrees in Finance and my busy year representing multiple buyers and sellers, here are my 6 observations on the supply and demand dynamics for the SF Peninsula real estate market.

1) Given previous major imbalance of high demand and limited supply, the exodus out of Bay Area has had only marginal little effect on purchase price for single family residences.

2) Renters may have accelerated their timeline to buy real estate than normal times, as SIP highlights one’s desire for more space.

3) Families living in an apartment or condo are more eager to purchase a property with outdoor space and/or more square footage. There seem to be more motivated move-up buyers who want a backyard.

4) Houses that are renovated and move-in condition are commanding more of a premium than even before. Buyers are less inclined to delay a move to do renovations.

5) Competitive multiple offers for houses that are nicely renovated, in good neighborhoods, and priced right. Others may sit on the market longer. In Sept, I had a beautiful 3bd SF listing that had 80 groups visit leading to 12 offers. The house next door with a couple issues went through multiple price cuts.

6) Buyers always try to balance between buying for lifestyle purposes and optimizing as an investment. SIP has greatly shifted the real estate buying decision to a quality of life value proposition.

Feel free to contact me anytime if you wish to talk real estate or say hi. Please “like” my Facebook Real Estate Page at https://www.facebook.com/PeterTaoProperties to stay updated on Bay Area real estate.

Top 6 Things I Hope Remain After Shelter-in-Place Ends

Please “like” https://www.facebook.com/PeterTaoProperties to see my latest SF Peninsula real estate updates and latest listings.

Shelter-in-place (“SIP”) started mid-March which has been challenging for everyone. While walking my dog daily, I have spent more time reflecting and observing. As the world hopefully gets closer to a vaccine, there are a handful of by-products of SIP that I hope will remain in some form post-pandemic: 

Old School Fun – Children are playing in the streets during the day and playing board games with their families in evening. I used to rarely see kids playing outside in the neighborhood given all the pre-scheduled activities. I am that cranky old guy lamenting about how I grew up riding bikes with friends and playing football/basketball/street hockey/ultimate frisbee, and whatever crazy games we made up. 

Less Traffic – Highway 101, San Mateo/Bay/Golden Gate/Dumbarton bridges and main local roads had gotten progressively worse since ten years ago. In the high technology-centric SF Bay, we were already leaders in remote work, but hopeful that more employees can work from home more regularly. Check out my good friend Ken’s company blog post on the “Future of Work” (https://e-m-marketing.com/2015/03/17/the-future-of-work-looks-bright-4-trends-to-cheer-about-infographic

Home Projects – My house is the most organized it has ever been. I have a) purged a dozen boxes of useless items in the garage and created a workout/yoga/game room, b) organized my drawers, closet and kitchen pantry, c) done more gardening, and g) done some interior painting while upgrading some design features in house.

Healthier Living and Yoga – Not eating out at restaurants has allowed for more nutritious meals at home. My BBQing game has ramped up a notch. During the 1st month of SIP, my lower back was in worse pain due to sitting for longer periods of time. I finally started yoga following Youtube videos; this has been a game changer as pain has significantly dissipated. I now own a yoga mat.

Basketball Shot – The kids and I have been practicing and playing a lot of basketball at our house. We’ve been regularly doing sets of 50 3 pointers and I’m now shooting 60-75%. I really miss playing pick-up basketball with my Bay Club friends. I hope my newfound shot and healthier back translates to on court performance.

Catching up with Friends and Clients – Zoom calling with out of town friends more frequently has been a primary source of meaningful social interaction. I have also gotten quite a numb of calls from friends/clients wanting to get my thoughts on various aspects of real estate such as remodelling, adding an ADU, possibly buying bigger property, investing or just seeing how the market is doing. SIP has really highlighted one’s home living conditions given both a remote work and distant school learning situation. I will have a separate blog post from a real estate perspective shortly based on my recent listings.

Anything you would add to your list post-pandemic?

Please “like” https://www.facebook.com/PeterTaoProperties to see my latest SF Peninsula real estate updates and latest listings.